Procrastination Assistance: Opinions Wanted!

This was an essay question on my “Jane Austen and Her Contemporaries” final exam:

Readers who don’t like Austen’s novels complain about the narrowness of her themes. They sometimes accuse her of ignoring the world outside her narrow society and of forsaking broader, historical—and more “important”—themes for a relatively small set of preoccupations and concerns. How would you respond to such a critic?

I have my own response already written that I’m planning on sharing, but first I’d like to hear from some others. What do you think? Are Jane Austen’s themes too narrow? Does she ignore historically important events? I would like to get a good  discussion started, so let me know your opinion in the comments! 🙂

Facebooktwittergoogle_plusredditpinterestlinkedinmailby feather

2 thoughts on “Procrastination Assistance: Opinions Wanted!

  1. The fact that she doesn’t mention war (for example), despite the fact that her brothers were almost all military, and there was always danger of a French invasion, makes her work timesless. She keeps the spotlight on the domestic sphere of her own class.

    • Thank you! That’s basically how I feel as well. I’ve written up a lengthier response, though, that I’ll probably post in a day or two and would love to have you weigh in on 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *